Nora and I have been playing World of Warcraft (WoW) for a few months now, and it's clear there are some things the game and the community built around it do very well, and some things they don't do so well.
The greatest strength is the variety of play. It's easy to go on quests and adventure through the world by yourself, and this is very rewarding in itself. It's also very simple to find and adventure with folks that you already know. Nora and I spend quite a bit of time collaborating in our two person group. When we're up for a challenge, we choose quests that are at or a little above our characters' levels. If we want some quick accomplishments, we go after the stuff we're a little too powerful for. The spectrum is broad here. This is one of WoW's greatest strengths. If we want easy, there's easy, if we want difficult, there's difficult. If we don't want to kill stuff, we can go fishing, or spend time on any of the game's other professions. These professions all have rewards for excellence, and each has its own tone, style and feel.
Blizzard, the company behind the game, has also developed a deep player versus player environment. Again, the power generally belongs to the players. There are specific areas to go if one wants to join a large battle. In these areas the rules are clearly defined (think Capture the Flag and King of the Hill), and one can drop out at any time. The more wins a character accumulates, the greater the rewards. There is also the option to play in a more general player versus player environment. This decision must be made at character creation. If you accept this challenge, you are forevermore allowed into conflict with members of the opposing faction. However, even here there are some rules in place. For example, you cannot be attacked within your own capital city or starting low level starting area, unless you initiate the combat. In neutral areas, however, all bets, and rules are off. Some of us adhere to some general rules of honor, but many do not.
There are some things missing from the WoW experience: I haven't seen any puzzle or musical quests, for example. There's a lot of harvesting, killing bad guys are vicious animals, fetching artifacts usually guarded by bad guys or animals. Aside from those fundamentals, there isn't much variety. The types of adversaries, and the environments in which they live varies, but the activities surrounding them generally don't.
Now that I wrote that, I remembered some a counter examples. During the Halloween season, there IS a special event, and as part of that event, characters must use buckets of water to put out fires caused by the WoW version of the Headless Horseman. In the WoW "Brewfest" there was a quest to ride a ram throughout the city to advertise the beer garden outside the city gates.
Maybe later I'll write my own personal code of honor for player versus player battling.
